New IT Prequel Struggles to Capture King’s Chilling Essence

NEW YORK, N.Y. — HBO‘s new series, IT: Welcome to Derry, premieres October 26, 2025, at 9 p.m. ET/PT. The show acts as a prequel to Stephen King’s iconic novel and its adaptations, showcasing events in the town of Derry during the 1960s.

The series splits into two narratives. One focuses on the well-known horror elements of King’s IT, featuring a group of kids as they confront Pennywise, the infamous clown. Unfortunately, critics suggest this segment struggles to deliver depth, often relying on cheap scares instead of meaningful horror.

A standout scene unfolds when a child named Matty Clements encounters a grotesque incident in a car with a seemingly normal family. The sequence, rife with unsettling imagery, sets a dark tone for the series but ultimately offers little in terms of character development.

In another narrative thread, viewers meet Major Leroy Hanlon, played by Jovan Adepo. His storyline delves into military themes and Cold War tensions but feels disconnected from the child-centric plot. Critics argue this divide contributes to a jarring viewing experience, lacking cohesion between the two narratives.

The performances of the young cast, including Clara Stack as Lilly Bainbridge, fail to resonate due to the weak writing and character development. Many cheers for nostalgia fade quickly as the kids’ dialogues come off as forced and overly scripted. This inconsistency leaves audiences wanting a more authentic portrayal akin to King’s original characters.

Though the series hints at exploring significant issues such as racism and military history, it skims the surface instead of providing meaningful commentary. The attempts at thematic depth often appear overshadowed by the gore and fright, leaving critics questioning the direction and purpose of the show.

Ultimately, while IT: Welcome to Derry seeks to expand the lore surrounding Pennywise and Derry, its execution appears to be its most significant weakness. With a mix of horror, societal issues, and childhood struggles, the show aims high but risks losing its audience amid the chaos.

New episodes will air weekly on Sundays, continuing to explore the chilling world of IT while leaving fans wondering if the series can deliver a story worthy of King’s legacy.