Casting Call: New Character for ‘Yellowstone’ Spinoff Sparks Speculation

LOS ANGELES, March 14, 2025 — A forthcoming spinoff of the popular television series ‘Yellowstone‘ focused on Beth Dutton and Rip Wheeler is set to shake up casting dynamics as the hunt for a ‘Kevin Costner-type’ actor intensifies.

Since its announcement in December 2024, the series, created by Taylor Sheridan, has generated anticipation among fans eager to see Kelly Reilly and Cole Hauser reprise their beloved roles. According to industry newsletter reports, producers are seeking an actor reminiscent of Kevin Costner, who portrayed John Dutton in the flagship series until its Season 5 finale, during which his character met a shocking end.

Sheridan’s latest updates reveal that discussions surrounding casting are ongoing, with names such as Mark Harmon, John Malkovich, and Dennis Quaid mentioned by fans as potential successors to Costner. The inquiry into who could embody the tough yet charismatic spirit of Costner has ignited conversations across social media platforms.

“Costner is impossible to replace, but if they must, I would pick Brandon Sklenar,” suggested one fan, citing Sklenar’s current role in another Sheridan series, ‘1923.’ Others echoed support for Quaid, noting his similar screen presence to Costner. “He brings a very similar screen presence to Kevin Costner and would feel right at home on ‘Yellowstone,’” remarked a fan.

These developments come on the heels of a controversial season that framed Beth’s storyline against the backdrop of a family betrayal and her father’s death. As viewers ponder how a new character could be incorporated, speculation also arises about the potential for conflict, especially given Beth’s past struggles with familial relationships.

“The absence loomed over the entirety of Season 5, and the new character’s presence will likely stir significant reactions from Beth,” noted a viewer, highlighting Beth’s challenges in accepting new faces and relationships after losing her father.

With the spinoff set to begin filming this summer, fans remain eager to see how Sheridan and his team will address the gap left by Costner’s departure, and whether or not they can capture the essence of a character that became iconic on the show.

As casting news continues to unfold, discussions have expanded beyond the possible successors of Costner, with suggestions ranging from A-listers like Harrison Ford and Ralph Fiennes to lesser-known talents. “Does it have to be another A-lister? Why not cast a relative unknown for once?” one comment read, showcasing the diversity of opinions surrounding the spinoff.

In addition to the upcoming spinoff focused on Beth and Rip, sources indicate that another spinoff project is also in development, suggesting that Sheridan’s universe will continue to expand, enticing both loyal fans and new viewers alike.