Elle Macpherson’s Cancer Treatment Sparks Discussion on Medical Choices and Misinformation

Media reports regarding Elle Macpherson‘s breast cancer treatment have raised concerns among medical professionals about potential misinformation. The supermodel, diagnosed with HER2 positive oestrogen receptive intraductal carcinoma in 2017, reportedly chose to avoid standard medical treatments such as surgery, chemotherapy, and radiation.

In her interview with the Australian Women’s Weekly, Macpherson stated that she followed an “intuitive, heart-led, holistic approach.” However, she did confirm that she underwent a lumpectomy, a surgical procedure that removes a breast lump. Expert opinions emphasize that a lumpectomy can be an appropriate treatment for certain cases of this type of cancer.

Professor Chris Pyke, a leading breast cancer surgeon, explained that HER2 positive oestrogen receptive intraductal carcinoma is often considered a non-invasive precancer. He noted that while some cases may turn invasive if left untreated, the likelihood is relatively low, and a lumpectomy alone might suffice in many instances.

The lack of detailed information in various media reports regarding the size and grade of Macpherson’s cancer, as well as other potential risk factors, has prompted scrutiny. Pyke highlighted that patients with early forms of breast cancer must be presented with all treatment options, which might include lumpectomy, radiotherapy, or mastectomy.

Experts also expressed concerns that Macpherson’s choices could mislead patients exploring alternative treatments. Kristen Pilatti from the Breast Cancer Network Australia emphasized the importance of informing patients about evidence-based treatment options before making decisions.

Leading surgeons and cancer specialists warned of the risk associated with opting for alternative therapies over conventional treatment methods. Professor Cindy Mak cautioned against the dangers of avoiding chemotherapy, particularly for patients with HER2-positive breast cancer.

Overall, medical professionals are advocating for patients to approach their treatment decisions with careful consideration and consultation with trusted health sources.