NFL Draft 2025: Quarterback Class Leaves Teams with Tough Decisions

INDIANAPOLIS, Ind. — As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, teams in search of a quarterback face a challenging decision-making process, with many opting to fill their roster gaps before the draft even begins. Notable teams like the New York Giants and Las Vegas Raiders have already made key signings to shore up their quarterback positions, leaving some to wonder about the implications of this trend.

In a strategic shift, NFL franchises are recognizing the value of securing quarterbacks early to avoid desperate drafts later. Many teams have filled vacancies in the offseason, while potential top picks, like the Carolina Panthers and Houston Texans, are left weighing their options at the top of the draft board. The focus has turned to whether they will select a quarterback or explore their alternatives.

However, the 2025 quarterback class does not carry the same weight as its 2024 predecessor, which showcased talents like Heisman winners and first-round draft picks. According to scouting reports, this year’s top prospects lack the same level of hype, leading to an unsettling uncertainty for franchises in need. Not only are the elite contenders less clear, but the remaining talent shows question marks, a reality that teams will need to confront come draft time.

This backdrop brings into play QBASE 2.0 projections, a method that merges historical quarterback performance data and mobility metrics to forecast players’ future success. The 2025 class appears less promising when it comes to immediate impact compared to previous years, with expectations pointing to teams potentially opting for second or third-round talent rather than first-round selections.

“Teams have to consider whether they need a long-term option, and in this class, that might not be available,” said Andrew Healy of QBASE. “Some might choose to trade up for a player they believe in, or they might find themselves waiting until next year to get their franchise quarterback.”

Leading the list of available prospects is Colorado‘s standout player, boasting versatility as both a wide receiver and cornerback. Analysts believe he could be the most impactful player in the upcoming draft. Other notable prospects include Penn State’s prolific playmaker, Michigan‘s dynamic athlete, and Arizona’s standout player, each potentially changing the trajectory of their respective franchises.

As teams prepare for the draft, the depth in positions like running back and tight end offers some comfort, with several reliable options available. The edge rusher group has also seen significant talent, expected to dominate early in the draft.

The 2025 NFL Draft is shaping up to be a watershed moment for franchises with pressing quarterback needs, presenting opportunities but also unveiling significant risks. Executive decisions will be closely watched as the teams navigate the complexities of a less robust quarterback class, hoping to find gems while avoiding pitfalls.