Reds Callihan Debuts Amid Storm, Team Faces Tough Decisions

CINCINNATI, Ohio — An unforgettable Tuesday marked the major league debut of Cincinnati Reds outfielder Matt Callihan against the St. Louis Cardinals. Drafted by the Reds in 2019, Callihan took the field wearing No. 32, a number well-known among fans.

Callihan’s new number, previously worn by reliever Justin Wilson, evokes memories of Reds legends like Tom Browning and Jay Bruce. Bruce’s celebrated home run in the ninth inning against the Houston Astros on September 28, 2010, leading to a 3-2 victory, remains a highlight in franchise history.

With the team currently vying for the NL Central championship, expectations for Callihan’s performance are high. While he faces pressure to fill Bruce’s shoes, the comparisons largely end at their shared position as left-handed outfielders.

Meanwhile, Elly De La Cruz, another Reds prospect, continues to struggle defensively. After committing 29 errors last year, he is tied for the league lead again this season, causing fans to suggest a position change to the outfield. However, recent examples, such as Pittsburgh Pirates‘ Oneil Cruz, show that such moves can backfire.

Despite De La Cruz’s size and speed, converting him to an outfield role may not guarantee improved performance. His seven errors this season heighten concerns as fans weigh his potential against current metrics.

Reds management is also dealing with closer Alexis Diaz, whose trade value has plummeted after a dismal start this season, recording a 12.00 ERA. Manager Terry Francona states Diaz must improve consistency, suggesting a trip to the minors for realignment may be necessary.

In positive news, outfielder Will Benson is showcasing promise at the Triple-A level, with an impressive .8881 OPS. His development could lead to a recall with the Reds facing ongoing performance challenges in their outfield.

As the Reds strive to find their footing in the tumultuous season, they are actively adjusting their roster, especially after a rain delay in their recent game against the Cardinals. With heavy rain disrupting play, there are questions about who will take the mound after the break, as Cincinnati looks to stabilize its pitching lineup.