Behind the Scenes of Bad Santa’s Troubled Production

LOS ANGELES, Calif. — Terry Zwigoff’s film Bad Santa premiered in 2003 and quickly became a holiday favorite. The story follows Willie, a foul-mouthed alcoholic portrayed by Billy Bob Thornton, who works as a department store Santa to rob the mall with his dwarf accomplice, Marcus, played by Tony Cox. Its unique blend of humor and holiday spirit earned it a loyal audience over the years.

However, the film faced numerous challenges during production. Initially, it was difficult to pitch an R-rated Christmas movie, resulting in Universal Pictures passing on the project. They deemed it misogynistic and anti-Christmas. Yet, Miramax’s Bob Weinstein acquired the rights, possibly attracted by the film’s controversial elements.

Complications arose even before filming began. Brett Kelly, who played Thurman Merman, contracted chickenpox and was sidelined for a week. Thornton’s drinking behavior also raised concerns; he was reportedly drunk and hungover on multiple occasions during shooting.

After struggling with poor test screenings, Weinstein requested reshoots, but Zwigoff resisted. As a result, Joker director Todd Phillips stepped in for uncredited reshoots, further complicating the production.

Casting proved to be another hurdle. Angus T. Jones was initially considered for Thurman, but the role ultimately went to Kelly. The search for Marcus was also challenging, with actors like Peter Dinklage and Mickey Rooney being considered before Tony Cox was chosen.

The lead role of Willie was particularly troublesome to cast. Robert De Niro and Bill Murray were both attached at different points but eventually dropped out. Others approached included Sean Penn, Nicolas Cage, and Jack Nicholson, but none accepted the role. Filmmakers even crafted scenes reflecting the rhythm of James Gandolfini‘s acting, who did not take the part despite previous collaboration with the Coen brothers on The Man Who Wasn’t There.

Despite the tumultuous production, Bad Santa emerged as a cult classic that continues to entertain audiences during the holiday season.