Tom Coughlin Declares Eli Manning the Greatest Big Game Quarterback

In a recent podcast appearance, former New York Giants head coach Tom Coughlin praised Eli Manning as the greatest “big game” quarterback he has ever witnessed. The statement was made during Coughlin’s guest spot on Barstool Sports‘ “Pardon My Take” where he extolled Manning’s performance during their tenure together with the Giants.

Discussing Manning’s ability to perform under pressure, Coughlin remarked, “He is the greatest — people will argue with me, I get it, but he’s the greatest big game quarterback that I’ve ever seen.” Coughlin and Manning famously led the Giants to two Super Bowl victories, in 2008 and 2012, both against the New England Patriots.

Manning’s play in critical moments was highlighted by Coughlin. He referenced the iconic “David Tyree helmet catch” in Super Bowl XLII and the “Mario Manningham sideline catch” in Super Bowl XLVI as evidence of Manning’s clutch abilities. “You talk about big play, big game people. Wow, I mean I’m taking him because I’ve seen him do it under any circumstance you can imagine,” Coughlin stated.

Coughlin coached the Giants from 2004 to 2015, during which time Manning established himself as a consistent playoff performer. Under Coughlin’s leadership, Manning threw for significant yardage and touchdowns, culminating in his selection as the Super Bowl MVP twice.

This discussion arises as Manning is considered an early candidate for induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. His impressive postseason resume, marked by two Super Bowl MVP honors and numerous game-winning drives, supports his eligibility for the prestigious accolade.

Eli Manning, known for his calm demeanor and steady hand in pressure situations, has been a topic of admiration and debate among football pundits and fans alike. Coughlin’s comments reignite the conversation about Manning’s legacy as one of the key figures in Giants history and his standing amongst the NFL’s legendary quarterbacks.