Cardinals Face Tough Decisions in Center Field Ahead of Season

ST. LOUIS, Mo. — As the St. Louis Cardinals embark on a youth movement in John Mozeliak‘s final year as general manager, the team faces tough roster decisions this offseason due to an inability to make trades. With star third baseman Nolan Arenado assured of regular playing time, five players are vying for three positions in the lineup, including second base, left field, and center field.

Currently, the Cardinals must consider the versatility of various players, chiefly Brendan Donovan, who can play both second base and left field. His potential placement in left field could shift Lars Nootbaar to center field while opening up second base for a newcomer. Conversely, keeping Nootbaar in left would allow Donovan to return to the infield and provide an opportunity for younger prospects like Victor Scott or Jonathan Siani in center.

Donovan and Nootbaar are effectively guaranteed everyday playing time, with one expected to solidify the starting left field position. Should Donovan claim that role, it would necessitate Nootbaar’s move to center, facilitating the inclusion of either Scott or Siani at second base. Both Scott and Siani became key players last season, sharing nearly 85% of the innings in center field.

Scott, a top-100 prospect, has long been associated with high offensive potential, but had minimal success in the majors last year, posting a .179/.219/.283 slash line. Despite these struggles, his minor league performance raised expectations, particularly his impressive 35 stolen bases last season.

Siani, 25, also struggled offensively last season with a .228 average but excelled defensively, recording 20 stolen bases and achieving a +16 Outs Above Average. Yet, his offensive potential appears capped, as he ranked among the lowest in offensive metrics despite his strong defensive capabilities.

The Cardinals’ center field situation remains complicated, with Tactical considerations about balance among offensive output and defensive prowess prompting debates about who should take on the role. Team momentum is essential; thus, enclosing Siani’s elite glove work against Scott’s speed and the hitting potential of Nootbaar and Donovan is critical.

Nootbaar, the most established hitter in the group, offers balance in the lineup but lacks the defensive prowess of Scott or Siani, raising questions on whether to sacrifice defense for offense. Gorman, who emerged as a strong hitter in the last season, poses another factor. He could earn playing time if Nootbaar shifts to center, yet struggles with his own performance last season.

As the team grapples with these complex evaluations, managerial choices will define the upcoming season. Cardinals players and fans alike await how the coaching staff will optimize their roster amid the blend of youthful potential and defensive reliability.