Controversial Try Decision in NRL Grand Final Scrutinized

The 2024 NRL Grand Final at Accor Stadium witnessed a contentious moment when Melbourne Storm‘s Jack Howarth was denied a crucial try against the Penrith Panthers. The incident occurred in the 49th minute, leaving fans and commentators divided over the decision made by the Bunker, the NRL’s video review system.

Xavier Coates, a winger for the Storm, executed a high-flying retrieval, passing the ball back infield to centre Jack Howarth. Howarth appeared to have fought through a robust defensive effort from Panthers players, including Izack Tago, Dylan Edwards, and Brian To'o, to ground the ball. However, referee Ashley Klein referred the decision to the Bunker as a ‘no-try’.

When the replays were shown on the large screens at the stadium, the 80,156 spectators reacted passionately, with Melbourne fans hopeful and Penrith fans tense. Expert commentators like Andrew Johns and Brad Fittler also differed in their assessments, with Johns believing the ball touched the ground, whereas Fittler pointed out that it seemed to be held up by Howarth’s arm.

The Bunker’s official, Grant Atkins, after reviewing multiple camera angles, upheld the referee’s call of no-try, stating, “At no point did the ball hit the ground.” NRL’s Head of Football, Graham Annesley, later justified the decision, citing clear video evidence that the ball was on top of Howarth’s arm.

This ruling kept Penrith ahead, and social media buzzed with debate over the call. Some fans and analysts challenged Atkins’ decision, questioning the consistency of officiating in crucial matches. Panthers coach Ivan Cleary, although critical of the Bunker’s role in prior matches, likely felt relieved by the result.

The potential try would have tied the game at 10-10, potentially putting Melbourne in the lead with the subsequent conversion. Storm coach Craig Bellamy, when asked about the decision, downplayed its significance, emphasizing the uncontrollable nature of the decision-making process in such scenarios.

This incident has reignited discussion about the role and impact of video technology in sports, with particular emphasis on the Bunker’s decision-making transparency. The Panthers, nevertheless, received commendation for their defensive display, which included notable performances from players like Liam Martin, who was instrumental in key moments of defense against Howarth and the Storm.