Strictly Come Dancing’s Latest Season Faces Familiar Backlash Over Contestants’ Previous Dance Experience

The upcoming season of “Strictly Come Dancing” is once again drawing attention and criticism due to some contestants’ prior dance training, leading to debates over fairness in the popular competition. The show, known for featuring celebrities from various backgrounds, often raises questions about the perceived advantage of those with previous performing arts experience.

In recent years, the show’s casting choices have led to complaints from viewers who argue that the inclusion of actors, singers, and performers—many of whom have formal training in dance or theatrical performance—creates an uneven playing field. For instance, last year’s contestant, Layton Williams, who performed in West End productions, faced similar scrutiny from audiences.

This season, contestants such as Tasha Ghouri, a former “Love Island” finalist, have been candid about the challenges they face despite their dance backgrounds. Ghouri, who trained at Creative Academy in Slough and specializes in commercial dance, noted that ballroom dancing presents a unique challenge. She told reporters at a roundtable event with “The Independent” that learning ballroom techniques involves “stripping down and relearning,” suggesting that her previous experience might not provide as much of an advantage as some might think.

Another participant, Aston Merrygold of boyband JLS, discussed his recent preparations. Merrygold, who has dance experience from music videos and live performances, previously won the “Strictly” 2012 Christmas special with a jive routine. He shared that his recent tour might have kept him physically fit but noted the new techniques required would still present physical challenges.

Similarly, actor Bobby Borthwick, who starred in “EastEnders,” brings his performance experience to the dance floor. Having won the 2023 Christmas special, Borthwick attributed his skills to training at the Sylvia Young Theatre School, which boasts alumni like Daniel Kaluuya and Amy Winehouse. Despite his success, Borthwick remarked to “The Independent” that adapting to ballroom dance styles remains daunting.

Toyah Willcox, a singer and actress noted for her West End performances, also joins the “Strictly Come Dancing” lineup. Willcox, whose experience spans four decades in music and acting, acknowledged to “The Independent” that the competition’s demands are distinct from anything she has encountered in her career.

The debate over fairness on “Strictly” continues, raising questions about the show’s direction and its implications for participants without professional dance training. This dynamic fosters discussions on balancing entertainment value with equitable opportunities for all contestants, maintaining the integrity of the “amateur” dance competition.