Buffalo Police Commissioner Joseph Gramaglia Steps Down Amid Leadership Shakeup

BUFFALO, N.Y. — Former Buffalo Police Commissioner Joseph Gramaglia has submitted his retirement paperwork, effective midnight Monday, following a meeting with Acting Mayor Chris Scanlon. Gramaglia, who was appointed by former Mayor Byron Brown in 2022, will return to his civil service rank of Captain.

Gramaglia clarified in a statement that he did not resign but was informed by Scanlon of the decision to move in a “different direction.” He expressed gratitude for his tenure, highlighting historic reductions in violent crime and shootings during his leadership. “It has been an honor of a lifetime to serve the residents of the City of Buffalo,” Gramaglia said.

Scanlon emphasized that the decision stemmed from differing philosophies on policing, particularly regarding quality-of-life crimes. “We need to make an emphasis on our nuisance crimes as well,” Scanlon said. He denied that police overtime concerns influenced the decision, though he acknowledged it as a pressing issue.

Buffalo Police Benevolent Association (PBA) President John Davidson criticized Gramaglia’s leadership, calling it “catastrophic” and citing low morale among officers. “The mental health and safety of our officers was never lower,” Davidson said. He accused Gramaglia of focusing on disciplinary issues and failing to support officers in high-pressure situations.

Deputy Commissioner Alphonso Wright, a 38-year veteran of the Buffalo Police Department, will serve as acting commissioner. Scanlon plans to nominate Wright for permanent confirmation by the Buffalo Common Council, praising his experience and leadership qualities.

Gramaglia’s departure marks a significant shift in Buffalo’s law enforcement leadership, as the city grapples with balancing crime reduction and officer morale.