Cleveland Guardians Face Lineup Concerns Ahead of ALCS Game 3

The Cleveland Guardians are contending with significant lineup issues as they prepare to face the New York Yankees in Game 3 of the American League Championship Series (ALCS). Offensive struggles have been apparent throughout the postseason, with particular focus on the performances of players in right field and behind the plate.

Recent statistics show that Guardians catchers, including Bo Naylor and Austin Hedges, have struggled considerably. They have amassed a record of 0 for 23 with nine strikeouts across seven postseason games. Similarly, those playing in right field, namely Jhonkensy Noel and Will Brennan, have only managed a collective 2 for 25 (.080), with just one walk, an RBI, and nine strikeouts.

Compounding these issues is the absence of David Fry, who has not played since sustaining an elbow injury midseason. Cleveland Manager Stephen Vogt has been unable to utilize Fry’s versatility beyond roles as a pinch or designated hitter, limiting tactical options late in games.

The Cleveland Guardians have sought the opinions of their “Guardians Insider Subtext” subscribers to determine who should start against the Yankees. Various suggestions have emerged, with some arguing for the inclusion of Hedges due to his defensive capabilities and experience, while others prefer Naylor for his hitting potential.

Viren from New Albany suggests, “David Fry should start at catcher even if he can’t throw out runners. Noel, at least, has been solid defensively.” Contrarily, Melinda from Cleveland advocates for Austin Hedges, stating he is the “better catcher” due to his experience and defensive prowess.

Despite differing views, the majority emphasize a strong defensive strategy given the team’s current offensive output. Fans like Terry from Peoria propose using Hedges for his ability to “save runs defensively,” and John from Los Angeles highlights Hedges’ handling of pitchers as a key factor.

Concern over offensive deficiencies persists, with figures like Jim from Durham noting that Cleveland is unlikely to win four of the next five games under the current conditions. Suggestions include starting Hedges for defensive security while considering early pinch-hit opportunities if necessary.

These debates highlight the tension between maximizing offensive and defensive skills within the Guardians’ lineup as they strive to overcome the Yankees at Progressive Field.