Florida Panthers Edge Maple Leafs in Overtime, Series Now 2-1

TORONTO, ON – The Florida Panthers defeated the Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3 in overtime on May 9, 2025, cutting the Leafs’ series lead to 2-1 in the Eastern Conference Semifinals.

Max Pacioretty scored the game-winning goal in overtime, preventing the Panthers from falling into a 3-0 hole in the series. Pacioretty’s scoring prowess has been instrumental, as he has registered six points in the three games since joining John Tavares and William Nylander on the top line.

The Maple Leafs took an early lead in Game 2 and seemed poised to extend their series advantage. However, the Panthers showcased resilience, capitalizing on a Key moment midway through the third period to force overtime.

William Nylander continued to impress with another strong performance, now having six goals and 13 points in eight playoff games this year. Leafs coach Craig Berube praised Nylander, noting his ability to thrive under pressure.

Game 4 is set for Sunday night at Florida’s Amerant Bank Arena. The Leafs will look to regain control of the series, while the Panthers aim to build on their overtime victory.

The Leafs’ special teams have drawn criticism, converting only one of eight power play opportunities in the series. By contrast, their penalty kill has struggled, allowing two goals on five chances. This aspect of their game will be crucial as the matchup shifts to Florida.

Panthers goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky, despite facing heavy shots, will need to elevate his performance to maintain their playoff hopes. With this overtime victory, the Panthers aim to shift momentum back in their favor.