Fantasy Football: Players Underperforming, Managers Face Tough Decisions

Chicago, IL – Several fantasy football players are struggling to meet expectations as the 2025 season progresses, leaving managers to navigate difficult decisions. Key players are averaging lower points and receiving fewer targets, creating lineup dilemmas for many.

Williams, a wide receiver anticipated to have a breakout season, has averaged 7.9 fantasy points per game, a marked drop from 14.1 in 2024. Despite being part of the top-scoring offense in Detroit, he has not surpassed 50 receiving yards in four of five games. “Williams is indeed a letdown so far this season,” said a sports analyst, adding that he may simply serve as a bye-week replacement for the time being.

McBride ranks as TE4 with an average of 12.2 points per game. While he sees ample targets, limited red zone success and a struggling Cardinals offense are dampening his fantasy potential. With quarterback struggles contributing to his performance, McBride looks unlikely to provide high numbers anytime soon.

Brown of the Eagles is another player to watch. Although he had a standout game with 22.9 points in Week 3, he failed to score in four games since then. However, he has received a steady volume of targets in recent weeks, which could lead to resurgence against favorable upcoming matchups.

Nix, the quarterback for the Bears, is offering managers 16.8 points per game but has potential to improve. His dual-threat capability has shown promise, and with upcoming matchups against easier defenses, he could elevate his production.

Swift finds himself in a frustrating situation. Despite getting 14 carries per game, he struggles with efficiency, averaging only 3.3 yards per carry. Analysts believe his ability as a receiver keeps him relevant in flex positions, but improvements in his running game are necessary to boost his overall score.

Meyers from the Raiders started strong but has dipped below 10 points in the last three weeks. The quarterback situation is concerning, but a matchup against the Titans could provide an opportunity for his return.

Kamara has had a reduced workload and faces competition from teammate Miller, making him a risky choice moving forward. He is expected to see limited snaps in a struggling offense. Meanwhile, Higgins‘ production has plummeted to an average of 6.6 points over the last three games, but a new veteran quarterback could offer a revival.

As fantasy managers assess their lineups, key performance improvements from these underperforming players could prove crucial as the season progresses.