James Johnson Sparks Controversy in Game 3 for Pacers

INDIANAPOLIS, Ind. — In a crucial Game 3 matchup on May 10, 2025, the Indiana Pacers were struggling against the Cleveland Cavaliers, trailing by double digits for most of the night. With 5:03 remaining in the game and the score at 119-96, Pacers head coach Rick Carlisle made a surprising decision by inserting veteran forward James Johnson into the game.

The move raised eyebrows among commentators and fans alike. The broadcast team suggested that Carlisle’s decision could be meant to send a message to both his team and the Cavaliers. Johnson, who made only 12 appearances for the Pacers during the regular season, is known for his physical style of play.

Almost immediately after Johnson checked in, he set a hard screen on Cavs guard Max Strus and received a quick offensive foul. Shortly after, he appeared to throw a light elbow at Cavs center Evan Mobley, heightening the tension on the court. This unexpected behavior led to increased discussions on social media about the intent behind Carlisle’s choice.

In his brief five minutes on the floor, Johnson managed to score three points, grab one rebound, collect one steal, and commit one foul. Many fans reacted to his performance, some celebrating his entrance while questioning the logic of focusing on Johnson’s antics rather than the game itself.

Social media was abuzz with reactions, as fans expressed both confusion and amusement at Johnson’s immediate impact. “What an interesting decision” and “James Johnson plays basketball differently” were common themes in tweets and posts across various platforms.

The Pacers and Cavaliers will meet again for Game 4 at Gainbridge Fieldhouse on Sunday night at 8 PM EST, where fans will undoubtedly keep a close eye on how Johnson’s presence affects the team’s dynamics.