Judge Urges NCAA, Player to Resolve Antitrust Claims Independently

Nashville, Tennessee – A U.S. judge on October 16, 2025, encouraged the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) and Lipscomb University basketball player Derrin Boyd to settle their antitrust claims without further court intervention.

The comments came during a hearing where the plaintiff’s counsel indicated that they have been involved in “soft” discussions regarding the dispute. They expressed that they remain “very open” to resolving the matter amicably.

The claims center around the NCAA’s policies and their potential impact on student-athletes. Boyd’s legal team believes that these policies may violate antitrust laws, limiting fair compensation options for athletes.

The judge emphasized the importance of finding a resolution outside the courtroom, hoping it would lead to a quicker and more favorable outcome for both parties. The case highlights ongoing debates in college sports about the rights of student-athletes and their ability to profit from their name and likeness.

Boyd’s situation is part of a larger national dialogue regarding athletes’ rights and the evolving landscape of college athletics.

As discussions continue, both sides are expected to reassess their positions in light of the judge’s recommendations.