New Play ‘Neighborhood Watch’ Highlights Suburban Tensions After Election

CHICAGO, Ill. — A new play explores tensions in a predominantly white suburb after the 2024 election. Rehana Lew Mirza’s “Neighborhood Watch” premiered recently at Jackalope Theatre, directed by Kaiser Ahmed. It examines the reactions of a white man when a Muslim neighbor moves in next door.

The story opens with Paul, played by Frank Nall, a widowed father whose adult daughter Becca, portrayed by Jamie Herb, has returned home from college. Their lives change when Mo, a younger man played by Harsh Gagoomal, moves in next door, sparking a budding romance between him and Becca.

The first act is rife with humor stemming from cultural misunderstandings. Paul, embodying the liberal stereotype, offers a housewarming gift to Mo but struggles to communicate without making awkward comments. He even expresses relief that the neighborhood isn’t as “too white” anymore. Meanwhile, Mo finds amusement in playing off stereotypes, all while the romance between him and Becca unfolds.

As the relationship develops, so does Paul’s concern for his daughter, exacerbated by the influence of his MAGA neighbor Shawn, played by Victor Holstein. Shawn convinces Paul to spy on the couple, leading to a chain of paranoia and questionable decisions.

The second act introduces a new character, Javed, portrayed by Omar Bader, who brings drama from Mo’s past into play. Javed’s history of minor electronic crimes adds tension to the narrative, but some critics have said his speedy introduction affects pacing and development.

Although the play delivers plenty of laughs and touches on significant themes about stereotypes and suburban dynamics, critiques target its character depth. While Becca and Mo’s chemistry shines, Paul’s motivations feel oversimplified, hindering the emotional weight of the story.

“Neighborhood Watch” runs through June 28 at Broadway Armory Park and is priced between $15 and $40. Despite its rushed elements, the play offers entertainment and thought-provoking moments for audiences.