NFL Fantasy Surprises: Rookie Stars Shine as Season Progresses

IRVING, Texas — As the 2025 NFL season unfolds, fantasy football managers are navigating unexpected turns, particularly with rookies rising to prominence. With four teams still seeking their first win, the dynamic of this season is keeping fans engaged.

One player generating buzz is rookie running back A.J. Skattebo, who has increased his playtime in recent weeks. Following a strong performance against the Chiefs, where he scored 24.1 points, Skattebo is proving to be an essential asset for fantasy teams. “He invites contact and punishes defenders,” analysts noted, emphasizing his dual-threat capability as he averaged 5.0 yards per carry in the recent games.

Meanwhile, Chargers wide receiver Jalen Johnston is also making headlines with his deep-ball ability, averaging 18.6 points per game, and contributing significantly to the offensive scheme. Analysts are optimistic about his continued growth alongside quarterback Justin Herbert. “He provides a vertical element that is key for our offense,” remarked an insider.

Quarterback Daniel Jones of the Colts also offers a promising narrative. With a quick release and improved accuracy, he scored 15.8 points against the Patriots despite only completing 71.6% of his throws. Analysts believe his role will grow under coach Shane Steichen, solidifying him as a potential starter for fantasy teams.

However, not all surprising narratives are positive. Rookie running back Greg Dobbins from the Broncos, initially favored for his projected dual-threat role, has slipped behind teammate Gus Edwards in production, prompting speculations on his value.

On another note, tight end Hunter Henry has become a vital player for the Patriots, leading position scoring after a dazzling 29-point performance against the Jets.

Despite some struggles, a range of fantasy options continues to thrive. With the added unpredictability due to injuries and bye weeks, fans are witnessing an evolving landscape. Each week carries unique narratives that could define playoff races.