NFL Teams Face Dilemma with 2025 Quarterback Draft Class

IRVING, Texas — As the NFL approaches the 2025 draft, several teams are re-evaluating their quarterback strategies amidst a unique challenge. While teams such as the New York Giants and Las Vegas Raiders have taken proactive steps to fill their quarterback vacancies before the draft, others, including the Chicago Bears and Houston Texans, still find themselves in need of a reliable signal-caller.

This season’s reluctance to draft quarterbacks stems partly from the current class’s perceived lack of talent compared to previous years. Notably, last year’s draft featured standout prospects like Heisman winners Caleb Williams and J.J. McCarthy, creating a sense of urgency and excitement among teams. In contrast, the 2025 crop of quarterbacks is facing scrutiny.

According to prospects analysts, several teams, including the Giants and Raiders, may still pursue a quarterback in the top ten picks despite signing veterans. Giants’ General Manager Joe Schoen noted, “We had our eyes on potential acquisitions, but we also want to ensure we’re developing the right talent for the future.”

The NFL’s quarterback landscape is changing rapidly. After a season of strategic adjustments, options are narrowing. For teams like the New Orleans Saints, coping with the departure of their incumbent quarterback, the 2025 draft feels critical for their long-term success.

Moving forward, the analysis from Andrew Healy’s QBASE 2.0 combines college statistics and mobility metrics to project the potential success of quarterbacks entering the league. This predictive model gauges how well a quarterback could perform professionally, providing an analysis that factors in the quality of their college competition and team situation.

An important aspect of this year’s class is that many of the quarterbacks are not expected to be selected early. “We are looking at a scenario where non-first-round prospects could be the norm,” said draft analyst Dan Delaney. “Teams may have to wait until 2026 to secure a franchise quarterback.” This uncertainty can complicate strategic drafting for teams in need.

The top projections for QBs in the 2025 class speak volumes about the current talent level. Analysts are projecting high variance outcomes, with significant emphasis on a quarterback’s college experience and adaptability. For instance, while the average Total defense-adjusted yards above replacement per attempt suggests solid potential, many analysts warn that teams relying on it should prepare for the unpredictable nature of rookie performance.

Bears coach Matt Eberflus conveyed the sentiment of apprehension, stating, “We need a sustainable long-term approach in our quarterback roster. The incoming class might not offer what we hope for, but we must be ready either way.”

As teams like the Bears and Texans continue to navigate their options, it becomes clear that clarity in this year’s draft cycle is a challenging prospect. As the countdown to the draft intensifies, decision-makers are left pondering how to best address their quarterback needs in an uncertain landscape.