Should Andrew McCutchen Return to the Pirates in 2026?

Pittsburgh, PA — Andrew McCutchen is having a strong season at the plate, leading fans to wonder about his future with the Pittsburgh Pirates. As of May 7, 2025, McCutchen boasts a .255 batting average, placing third on the team. His slugging percentage stands at .402, and his on-base percentage is .350, contributing to an OPS of .752.

The 38-year-old veteran leads the team in doubles with six and ranks fourth in RBIs with 12. He also has three home runs this season. Despite his solid performance, the Pirates are struggling once again, raising questions about whether McCutchen will want to continue playing.

McCutchen’s current contract runs through the end of the 2025 season, valued at $5 million. Fans are now left to contemplate whether he should return to the team in 2026. This week’s SB Nation Reacts survey poses the question: Should McCutchen come back next year?

Fans are encouraged to cast their votes and share their opinions in the comments section. The results of the survey will be shared in an upcoming report.