Should Head Coaches Call Their Own Plays? Experts Weigh In

FRISCO, Texas – Dallas Cowboys staff writers addressed a crucial question in the latest installment of their ‘Mailbag’ series: Should a head coach also take on the responsibility of calling plays? This topic has sparked conversation among fans and analysts alike.

Marty Monforte from Endicott, New York, raised the inquiry, asking whether it’s beneficial for head coaches to call offensive or defensive plays, or if they should focus solely on overseeing the team while delegating those responsibilities to coordinators. He specifically wondered if a head coach’s performance might suffer if they take on both roles in their inaugural season.

Mickey Spagnola responded, referencing NFL legends like Tom Landry and Bill Parcells, who effectively managed both coaching and play-calling. He pointed out that Mike McCarthy called plays during the Cowboys’ successful 12-5 season in 2023. Spagnola argued that a head coach who has proven themselves as a coordinator should continue contributing in that capacity, especially in their first year.

Tommy Yarrish added a more nuanced perspective, noting that some coaches excel as play-callers, while others struggle and find success by delegating. He emphasized the need for each coach to evaluate their situation and decide whether to call plays or oversee the entire team. Brian Schottenheimer will begin as both head coach and play-caller this season, with the flexibility to reassess his approach as needed.

As the discussion unfolds, fans eagerly await to see how Schottenheimer balances his dual roles in the upcoming season and whether this strategy will impact the Cowboys’ performance.