St. Thomas Basketball’s Historic Journey to Division I Unfolds

ST. PAUL, Minn. — St. Thomas University is redefining its identity as it makes a historic transition to Division I basketball, with the Tommies poised for a spectacular season despite the challenges of eligibility. On a chilly evening in March, the excitement among alumni and former players at the Anderson Athletics Complex is palpable as they gather to support their alma mater.

Notably in attendance is Johnny Tauer, Ph.D., the head coach who has seen the program’s successful leap from Division III to Division I. Since taking the helm in 2015, Tauer has guided the Tommies to a remarkable transformation, reflecting on his journey from tenured professor to a full-fledged Division I coach. “You kind of pinch yourself,” Tauer stated. “These are the nights that are about as good as it gets in college basketball, short of March Madness.”

The Tommies, who were effectively removed from Division III in 2021 due to their size and success, have the potential to create a significant mark in NCAA history. However, due to regulations, the team will not be allowed to compete in the NCAA Tournament until 2026. Despite this, the Tommies have garnered considerable attention after a strong season, earning the best KenPom rating of any mid-major school.

Alumni have expressed their pride and future aspirations for the program, with Coach Tauer urging them to support the momentum and embrace the challenges ahead. “In many ways, it’s a metaphor for life,” he said, emphasizing the importance of seizing opportunities and making the right decisions. The St. Thomas athletic program has changed dramatically over the past few years, owing to a decline in their MIAC affiliation and an ambitious new identity in the Summit League.

Phil Esten, the university’s athletic director, shared insight into the decision to transition to Division I. “It was jarring for alumni and for the community,” Esten noted. “We have been figuring out our next steps ever since.”

Backed by significant renovations—such as the transformation of athletic spaces and development of new facilities—the program is ambitious in molding itself to meet the standards expected at the Division I level. As Athletic Director Esten mentioned, “If you look at our profile—our enrollment, our endowment—we look a lot more like Creighton and Marquette than we do other schools.”

The Tommies have already begun to prove their mettle on the court. Despite challenges in transitioning to Division I competition, their performance has reflected a strong commitment to growth. Key players, such as Kendall Blue and Drake Dobbs, have contributed to the team’s success with notable performances. “We’re motivated to make a name for ourselves,” Blue said, highlighting the team’s determination to showcase their capabilities even without a chance at postseason play.

The anticipation for the upcoming Summit League Tournament remains high, as the Tommies aim to secure another victory and build on their momentum. This season represents not just a chance to compete but a celebration of the university’s spirit and resilience in the face of adversity. Coach Tauer and his team are eager to demonstrate that their journey is just beginning, and that St. Thomas basketball is determined to leave a significant mark in college sports.