Undefeated MLS Teams Face Crucial Matches Ahead of Transfer Window

COLUMBUS, Ohio – As the 2025 Major League Soccer (MLS) season heats up, the Columbus Crew find themselves among the league’s seven undefeated teams, despite facing challenges during the preseason. This weekend, they will host New York City FC in a pivotal Matchday 5 clash.

In a dramatic turn of events during February, two key players from the Crew’s successful 2024 season were transferred out—star striker Cucho Hernández to Real Betis and another striker traded away, leaving only one original piece of their attacking trio. The Crew have adapted under head coach Wilfried Nancy‘s philosophy, managing to maintain their unbeaten record with a mix of strategy and resilience.

“You gut the attack that got you the best season in club history and you’re still undefeated? That is Wilfried Nancy’s legacy right there,” MLS analyst Andrew Wiebe said on a recent broadcast.

The Crew’s roster flexibility has prompted discussions about potential high-impact signings as the Primary Transfer Window approaches its closing on April 23. With the smallest squad in the league, the Crew is reportedly looking to fill at least one, if not two, Designated Player (DP) spots.

“They’re looking to fill those Designated Player spots right now,” Wiebe noted. “What they’re lacking is punch up top, and that can change quickly.”

The upcoming match against NYCFC will test the Crew’s depth and strategy further, particularly with some players going on international duty.

“They’ve got to get some signings in,” Wiebe added, emphasizing the importance of bolstering the squad. “Even while losing big pieces, the Crew are absolutely that team,” referring to their capacity to still contend effectively.

Meanwhile, across the league, teams are adjusting to their respective seasons, and some face dire situations. The Seattle Sounders, for example, are struggling with goalscoring ahead of their match against Houston Dynamo after starting the season with only one win and significant roster challenges.

Sounders’ head coach Brian Schmetzer expressed frustration regarding their finishing touches. “We need good product and build-up in the final third. That’s what we’re working on this week,” he remarked, highlighting the necessity for improvement as they forge ahead.

Houston Dynamo, currently near the bottom of the league standings, also seek their first victory of the season, making their encounter with Seattle crucial for both teams. Dynamo head coach Ben Olsen shared his optimism following a recent friendly win against the El Salvador national team that might boost team morale.

“Even if it was only a friendly win, we threw some players into it, and you could see the relationships start to build,” Olsen said.

The stakes are particularly high in a league where performance can pivot dramatically with strategic signings and player development. As the weekend approaches, eyes are eagerly watching how each undefeated team manages the pressure and adjusts to not only maintain their successful starts but also address impending roster changes.