Angel City’s Eddy Faces Backlash for Op-Ed on Trans Athletes

Los Angeles, CA – Elizabeth Eddy, a player for Angel City FC, faced criticism from her teammates after publishing an op-ed on trans athletes in the National Women’s Soccer League (NWSL) on October 26. Eddy’s piece, shared on social media platform X, responded to reports about the NWSL’s unclear policy regarding trans and intersex athletes.

In her article, Eddy expressed concern that without clear guidelines on inclusion, the league could lose its identity and momentum. She called for a ban on trans athletes to protect “the integrity of women’s sports.” However, Eddy did not provide evidence to support her claims about the league’s integrity being compromised.

Since its inception, the NWSL has established itself as a strong competitive force in women’s soccer. Viewership has reportedly increased every season, and the league plans to expand to 16 teams by 2026, nearly doubling its size in five years.

Eddy cited the English FA’s success in addressing trans athletes in women’s soccer, but the policy reportedly affects only about 20 grassroots players out of 5.5 million registered athletes in the UK. In the U.S., the NWSL has had only two trans players in its history – both of whom have since left the league.

Currently, there are no out trans players competing professionally in the United States. A lack of federal legislation has made it challenging for trans athletes to participate in NCAA college soccer. Notably, studies show trans athletes do not have a biological advantage over their cisgender counterparts.

The topic of trans inclusion has remained controversial. Players like Barbra Banda of the Orlando Pride faced online abuse after being recognized for their achievements. Eddy’s teammates expressed disappointment with her article. Captain Sarah Gorden stated, “That article does not speak for this team in this locker room.” Gorden further criticized the harmful implications of the op-ed, particularly its call for genetic testing and the accompanying photo of Banda, which she found detrimental.

Critics argue the op-ed diverts attention from pressing issues within the league, including claims of racial discrimination and poor working conditions. Six former employees of the San Diego Wave filed complaints alleging various forms of discrimination and negligence by the NWSL.

Health and safety concerns have also emerged, such as a player collapsing during a match, which highlighted the need for improved medical protocols. With other leagues gaining financial strength, concerns about player retention have grown. Eddy’s position on trans inclusion appears disconnected from these significant challenges facing the NWSL.