Colts Face Major Decisions as Free Agency Approaches

INDIANAPOLIS, Ind. — As free agency looms, the Indianapolis Colts are charting a different course than last year when they retained many of their in-house free agents. This offseason, the team has only re-signed six players, with one contract modification, compared to the 12 players brought back in 2024.

Several notable players, including Ryan Kelly, Will Fries, and Dayo Odeyingbo, have departed to join other teams. With 12 of their own free agents still on the market, questions abound about who may return and who will move on.

The official start of free agency is just days away, creating an atmosphere of urgency among fans and players. General manager Chris Ballard has notably prioritized retaining current players in past offseasons, casting uncertainty on the Colts’ approach to acquiring new talent this time around.

The status of key players is now in question. Veteran quarterback Joe Flacco, 40, is expected to exit Indianapolis, while fellow quarterback Sam Ehlinger’s future remains uncertain. Although the Colts seem prepared to slot Ehlinger as the QB3, his youth and potential have many wondering about his long-term role with the team.

“It’s tough to gauge what we’ll do right now. Some guys have established their worth, and it’s a balancing act,” Ballard said in a recent interview.

Running backs Tyler Goodson and Trey Sermon have also had their contracts up in the air. Goodson secured a one-year extension through 2025, but neither has made a significant impact behind star running back Jonathan Taylor. Analysts speculate that the Colts may draft a running back, creating further doubts about Sermon’s future.

Special teams standout Ashton Dulin, 28, has contributed significantly, although he has battled injuries since 2023. “I want to stay where I’ve found success,” Dulin stated, hinting at his hopes for a contract renewal.

The tight end position presents its own challenges, with Moore Alie-Cox expressing a desire to find a more competitive environment. In contrast, tight end Kylen Granson seems destined to leave Indianapolis.

The Colts face additional uncertainty with offensive linemen Kelly and Fries, both of whom are perceived as risky investments due to injuries and inconsistencies. Kelly has been vocal about his preference to remain in Indianapolis, but team sentiments appear to diverge.

“We’re evaluating everyone closely. The injuries have made it even more challenging,” Ballard added.

Defensive strategies are also under review as free agents like E.J. Speed and Grant Stuard enter the market. While there’s a possibility of retaining them for depth, their performances in past seasons raise eyebrows.

Amid these decisions, cornerbacks Chris Lammons and Tre Flowers may face the chopping block as the organization seeks to overhaul the secondary. “We need to see major improvements in that area,” one analyst noted.

As free agency rapidly approaches, the Indianapolis Colts find themselves at a crossroads, with critical decisions to make regarding their roster. The outcomes may significantly shape the Colts’ performance in the upcoming season, making this period a pivotal point in their organizational strategy.