Yankees Fans Face Dilemma: Blue Jays or Dodgers?

NEW YORK — Yankees fans are experiencing a rare predicament this October. For the first time in franchise history, they must choose between rooting for the Toronto Blue Jays, their longtime rival, or the Los Angeles Dodgers, a team that shares a big-market reputation. The situation is complicated by former Yankees captain Don Mattingly, now the manager of the Blue Jays, who is finally making his mark on baseball’s biggest stage.

The New York Post highlighted fan anguish on October 24 with the phrase, ‘Do it for Donnie,’ reflecting a split among Yankees fans of different generations. Traditionally, these fans follow a straightforward postseason script: root against Boston, avoid division rivals, and prefer National League teams over American League. This year, however, the Dodgers fit that mold, posing no threat to the Yankees’ playoff position.

While the Dodgers’ success would be a reminder to Yankees’ management of the benefits of aggressive spending, the Blue Jays present a much more immediate concern. With playoff hopes dashed by Toronto’s recent victory over New York, the notion of endorsing a direct competitor feels like an act of betrayal.

“It reminds me of Giants fans who said they couldn’t root for the Eagles in the Super Bowl because of rivalries,” said Brandon London on Back Page Banter. “The idea of supporting Toronto feels like breaking the code.”

This ‘code’ of loyalty is deeply ingrained in Yankees culture. The unspoken rules dictate never to cheer for rivals like Boston or Houston, and certainly never for division opponents like Toronto. London stressed, “If you’re a Yankees fan, there’s a code, and it’s New York or nowhere.”

Despite enduring countless October disappointments, Yankees fans have consistently adhered to these guidelines. Yet the significance of Mattingly’s legacy adds a layer of complexity. A six-time All-Star and a beloved figure in pinstripes, Mattingly never won a World Series during his 14-year career. Now at age 64, he leads the Blue Jays into the World Series, the same team that recently eliminated the Yankees.

“Yankees fans are grappling with a tough question: Do you cheer for your divisional rival for the sake of Donnie Baseball?” London posed. “Will it be standing by the code, or rooting for the man who has always been New York’s guy?”

For some, supporting Toronto could have long-term implications. A Blue Jays championship might encourage their front office and raise the stakes in the AL East, making life tougher for New York. Conversely, others think a title might breed complacency within the Toronto ranks.

The sentiments vary among fans, especially along generational lines. Older fans who remember Mattingly’s elegance and dedication may find it challenging to separate their loyalty from their nostalgia. In contrast, younger fans may prioritize their rivalry with Toronto over history.

The debate has ignited social media, with some fans endorsing the #DoItForDonnie campaign, while others firmly state, ‘anybody but Toronto.’ Mixed feelings may prevail, as many fans appreciate Mattingly’s achievement without extending their support to the Blue Jays.

Historically, baseball fans have navigated similar dilemmas while remaining loyal to their teams. For now, the Bronx stands firm, ready to respect and honor Don Mattingly’s legacy while upholding the time-honored rule: New York or nowhere.