New Comedy ‘Overcompensating’ Explores Queer Identity in College

LOS ANGELES, CA — The new Prime Video comedy series, “Overcompensating,” centers around Benny Scanlon, a closeted gay college freshman, played by Benito Skinner. The show explores themes of identity and conformity as Benny navigates the challenges of fitting in at college while concealing his true self.

Set during Benny’s first day at college, the series opens with him bonding with Carmen, played by Wally Baram, during orientation. Although eager to impress, Benny’s motivations stem from a desire for acceptance within a hyper-masculine culture, leading him to engage in a charade with Carmen to mask his attraction to men.

<p“The immense temptation to maintain a façade is corrosive. Even if it feels like a comedy, it’s about breaking free from societal norms of masculinity,” said Skinner, who co-created the series and draws inspiration from his own experiences.

In one humorous yet telling scene, Benny cleverly sidesteps a question from other male students about his sexual exploits, claiming he is “on the case” regarding his supposed interest in women. This comedic approach masks a deeper issue—a struggle for authenticity amid societal pressures.

As the series progresses, Benny’s friendship with Carmen becomes central to the narrative, evolving into a poignant exploration of love and self-discovery. Middle through the season, Benny opens up to Carmen about his sexuality, prompting her to take on the role of his guide in navigating queerness.

“Carmen’s growth parallels Benny’s, as both characters grapple with their identities in a humorous yet heartfelt manner,” added Skinner.

The series features an impressive cast, including Rish Shah as Miles, Benny’s crush, while the supporting roles add comedic lightness to the poignant themes of identity and acceptance.

What makes “Overcompensating” particularly engaging is its ability to shift from humor to emotional depth, a balance achieved through witty dialogue and relatable character arcs. The pilot episode’s use of Britney Spears‘ song “Lucky” poignantly underscores Benny’s internal conflict, encapsulating the feeling of longing for acceptance.

All eight episodes of “Overcompensating” are now available for streaming on Prime Video, offering a unique blend of humor and drama that resonates with viewers navigating their identities.