Orioles Trade Austin Hays in Head-Scratching Move

Just days away from the trade deadline, the Baltimore Orioles have made a surprising move by trading away outfielder Austin Hays. Unlike expected trades that usually involve sending off prospects for established MLB players, this deal sees the Orioles parting ways with an experienced player.

In the trade, the Phillies received Hays, while the Orioles welcomed right-handed pitcher Seranthony Domínguez and outfielder Cristian Pache. The announcement came with no prior media leaks, catching many off guard.

Upon hearing about the trade, one can’t help but wonder, why did the Orioles make this move? On the surface, it doesn’t seem to solve any pressing issues for the team, outside of possibly resolving the awkwardness of Hays sitting on the bench.

Let’s break down the newcomers. Domínguez, who is 29 years old, has had some decent seasons in the big leagues, but 2024 hasn’t been his best year. With a 4.75 ERA and 4.26 FIP, fans are left questioning if he can regain his form from 2022. His addition might mean the departure of Bryan Baker, but the $8 million team option for next year adds another layer to consider.

Then we have Cristian Pache, only 25 and already on his third team in three years. Despite once being hailed as a top prospect, he has struggled at the plate, hitting just .179/.243/.272 over his five major league seasons. The Orioles might be hoping to harness his defensive skills as they look to tweak their outfield.

For context, Hays was an All-Star just last year, but his performance has dwindled since that highlight. With the arrival of younger players like Colton Cowser and Heston Kjerstad, Hays’ role had diminished, making this move seem even more surprising.

Trade rumors had hinted that the Phillies might be interested in another outfielder, Cedric Mullins, while the Orioles were aiming for a more balanced right-handed outfield. Yet, they chose to trade away a productive righty for another righty with a rocky track record. This trade leaves fans scratching their heads.

As the trade deadline approaches, it opens up possibilities for further moves. With the Oriels’ willingness to make trades involving veteran players, speculations grow about what other surprises might unfold. Will they stick to these veteran swaps, or maybe look to trade for pitching help by parting with some prospects? Time will tell.