Pete Alonso’s Future Uncertain as Mets Focus on Defense

LAS VEGAS — The future of Pete Alonso is shaping up to be the biggest topic of discussion for the New York Mets this offseason as general managers’ meetings kick off this week. The Mets are keen on Alonso’s power production, but they aim to improve their defense, complicating his return to the team.

Alonso, who is now a free agent, stands out as the top option in the first-base market. Mets president of baseball operations David Stearns has indicated a strong desire to enhance ‘run prevention.’ This may lead to Alonso taking on more duties as a designated hitter, a position he hasn’t played significantly during his career.

If Alonso does not return, the Mets could explore internal options. Players like Jeff McNeil, Mark Vientos, and Brett Baty may shift positions to accommodate defensive upgrades. McNeil’s versatility could allow him to play first base, even as the Mets may look to address their defensive shortcomings elsewhere on their roster.

Alonso’s potential absence raises questions about who could fill his role. Some observers believe players accustomed to other positions could adapt to first base, allowing for creative solutions across the lineup. If Alonso stays, the Mets face a balancing act between his offensive prowess and defensive limitations.

Stearns’ experience with the Milwaukee Brewers shows a history of successfully adapting player roles to strengthen the lineup. Teams now view Alonso as a candidate that could clinch a hefty contract elsewhere, especially given that he had a much improved performance in 2025, ranking among the top in major leagues for RBIs and extra-base hits.

The Mets’ defense, particularly weak in the infield and outfield last season, may lead them to reconsider their roster structure. They might ask players like Brandon Nimmo, the left fielder with a full no-trade clause, to take on more designated hitter duties, while attempting to keep Juan Soto at right field.

In trade talks, starting pitcher Senga is reportedly drawing interest, and teams may see him as a low-risk addition following his injury troubles last season. With Senga’s salary manageable at $28 million over two years, his situation remains in flux as the Mets contemplate their rotation for the upcoming season.

While the Mets aim to regain competitiveness after missing the playoffs, Alonso’s future hangs in the balance amid varied suggestions from his agent about possibly transitioning to designated hitter. Alonso’s durability could influence negotiations with other teams that manage first base and DH positions more strategically.