Riley Greene’s Struggles Could Haunt Tigers in Playoffs

DETROIT, Mich. — After a promising start to the 2025 season, Detroit Tigers outfielder Riley Greene has fallen into a severe slump, raising concerns ahead of the Wild Card round against the Cleveland Guardians.

In June, Greene was hitting well, leading the Tigers in offensive production. However, since then, his performance has drastically declined, with September proving particularly challenging. As the Tigers gear up to face the Guardians at Progressive Field, Greene’s struggles could impede the team’s chances of advancing.

Greene’s rough stretch began earlier in the season but intensified as the pressure mounted. Beat writers have commented on his uncommunicative demeanor, framing his responses as disinterest. This has led to a cloud of criticism around the young player, who is still discovering how to handle the high stakes of professional baseball.

Known for his keen approach to the game, Greene is undergoing difficulties in timing and plate discipline. Metrics show an alarming increase in his swing-and-miss rate, which has hurt his effectiveness this season. His strikeout rate has climbed well over 30%, and he is now facing pitches that exploit his weaknesses more than ever.

Statcast data indicates Greene’s attack angle and swing pathway haven’t significantly deviated, suggesting that the issue lies within his timing rather than his mechanics. He’s swinging at pitches over the plate but failing to connect, often late on fastballs that he once would have driven. Observations from recent games show a consistent pattern of Greene making contact with pitches but struggling to make solid hits.

The Tigers have historically faced challenges against tough pitchers, and this year is no exception. Greene’s production is vital as the team prepares to face Guardians’ ace, Gavin Williams, known for his effective fastball and breaking pitches.

Greene’s recent performance, alongside the rise of other players like Jahmai Jones, puts the Tigers in a precarious situation heading into the playoffs. Jones has emerged as a key contributor, but his effectiveness against right-handed pitching remains a significant concern.

If Greene cannot adjust, it could mean a quick exit for the Tigers in the postseason. Manager A.J. Hinch faces tough decisions on how to position Greene without risking downtime that could cost the team crucial games.