Star-Studded Revival of Glengarry Glen Ross Opens to Mixed Reviews

NEW YORK, NY — On March 31, 2025, the Broadway revival of David Mamet’s Pulitzer Prize-winning play, “Glengarry Glen Ross,” premiered at the Palace Theatre. Directed by Patrick Marber, this highly anticipated production features a star-studded cast, including Kieran Culkin, Bob Odenkirk, and Bill Burr, all of whom leverage their significant television fame to draw audiences.

However, initial reviews have been mixed, with critics noting a lack of urgency and energy in the portrayal of the once high-stakes drama about unscrupulous real estate agents. This production appears overly reliant on its famous cast rather than the material itself. “What was once a fast-paced, no-holds-barred drama in which the plot takes on life-or-death stakes now feels like another day at the office,” remarked one critic.

The play tells the story of four Chicago real estate agents who resort to morally questionable tactics to survive in a cutthroat industry. Characters like Shelley Levene, played by Odenkirk, find themselves trapped in an increasingly desperate battle for sales, while Richard Roma, portrayed by Culkin, faces obstacles with his new client. The narrative highlights the lengths to which these agents will go to make deals, but critics argue that the production lacks the necessary intensity.

“Marber’s directorial touch is too delicate, and the production relies heavily on audience nostalgia for the story to elicit applause,” one review stated. Critics also pointed out that Mamet’s language, which once shocked audiences, now feels all too familiar in contemporary theatre.

The revival includes a set change during intermission, transitioning from a detailed Chinese restaurant backdrop to an office setting that has been ransacked, designed by Scott Pask. While both sets are artistically crafted, questions arose regarding the need for such an early intermission. Critics voiced concerns about the pacing and whether it effectively enhanced the storytelling.

Despite the show’s star power, performances from Broadway veteran Michael McKean and newcomer John Pirruccello received praise for bringing depth to Mamet’s characters. “The performances of McKean and Pirruccello give Mamet’s play heart and soul,” remarked one review. Their contributions stand out against the backdrop of their more famous co-stars, suggesting a hope that the revival could find traction through their efforts.

Running for approximately one hour and 45 minutes, including a 15-minute intermission, “Glengarry Glen Ross” features scenes laden with mature themes, including profanity and references to discrimination and violence, along with alcohol consumption.

Initial audience reception has shown mixed reviews, with an average approval rating of 75% on the aggregator Show-Score. As the production continues until June 28, the real question remains whether the performances will resonate beyond the celebrity appeal.

As the revival continues to unfold, it remains to be seen if this iteration of Mamet’s classic will connect with both critics and theatergoers alike.