Summer House Reunion Reveals Explosive Wedding Drama With Paige and Craig

NEW YORK, NY — Paige DeSorbo shared explosive details about her ex-boyfriend Craig Conover during the Season 9 reunion of “Summer House” on Wednesday, June 4. DeSorbo revealed that Conover was asked to leave the reception of Amanda Batula and Kyle Cooke‘s 2021 wedding due to his unruly behavior.

“Was he asked not to return to the backyard? Absolutely,” said DeSorbo, 32. She admitted that Conover, 36, was causing a scene, shouting, and ignoring the Batulas’ request for guests to stay outside.

Amanda Batula confirmed the incident, stating, “Craig was told to leave our property.” DeSorbo explained that she woke up the following morning and urged Conover to apologize to Mr. and Mrs. Batula for his actions. However, she said he refused to take responsibility. “I was mortified,” DeSorbo confessed.

DeSorbo painted a vivid picture of Conover’s drunken antics that night. “He acted like an entitled brat at the wedding, and he was an embarrassment,” she said. Rumors about the situation have circulated for years, and DeSorbo had previously accused a former castmate of leaking details to the media.

In a June 2024 interview, Conover claimed the story was “made up” and insisted he was not kicked out but was asked not to return inside. He stated, “It was a filmed event. If I was kicked out, we would’ve seen it on TV.” But Kyle Cooke, the groom, contradicted him, asserting that Conover was indeed removed from the wedding.

After their split in late 2024, DeSorbo expressed that she no longer feels the need to protect Conover. During the reunion, she shared the pressure she felt while dating him, stating, “Honestly, I’ve never had to lie in my entire life until I started dating him.”

The season 9 reunion captured the dramatic fallout, with DeSorbo addressing her relationship with Conover and the issues that led to their breakup.

As of now, DeSorbo is dating again but maintains it’s nothing serious, while Conover has also moved on. The wedding scandal is only one chapter of the ups and downs of their relationship, which has been heavily scrutinized by fans of the show.