IT: Welcome to Derry Lacks Supernatural Suspense, Fails to Impress

NEW YORK, NY — The much-anticipated HBO series, IT: Welcome to Derry, premieres on October 26, but early reviews suggest it fails to capture the horror and charm of its film predecessors. Set in 1962, the show focuses on the unsettling events in the town of Derry, Maine, as fear and mystery abound following a string of disappearances.

Directed by Andy Muschietti, who helmed the successful adaptations of Stephen King‘s IT, this prequel aims to dive deeper into the lore surrounding the titular entity. The story follows Captain Leroy Hanlon, portrayed by Jovan Adepo, a decorated military pilot who returns to Derry in search of answers amidst the chaos. Alongside him is his wife, Charlotte, and their son, Will, as they confront the secrets and horrors that linger in the seemingly idyllic town.

Despite high hopes, reviews highlight a lack of suspense and character depth compared to the films. While acknowledging the compelling performances, particularly by Adepo and Taylour Paige as Charlotte, critics argue that the younger cast does not evoke the same charm or chemistry as the original movies’ ensemble.

The series attempts to tackle significant themes like racism and military secrecy during the Cold War, yet many reviews point out that it lacks both urgency and genuine horror. Critics note that while some sequences are visually striking, the show struggles to create the tense atmosphere that characterized the films.

Pennywise, the iconic character from the original films, appears briefly, leaving fans craving more of the terror he embodies. The reviews suggest that the storytelling, which weaves between multiple characters and perspectives, disperses the narrative’s tension rather than consolidating it into a cohesive horror experience.

As viewers prepare for its release, many remain hopeful that the series can deliver more surprises in its upcoming episodes, despite the lukewarm initial reactions. The show’s narrative is presented through various lenses—children’s fears and adult soldiers’ dilemmas—which may resonate differently with audiences.

IT: Welcome to Derry beckons back fans of King’s universe, but with criticism looming, viewers hope the series finds its footing in the remaining episodes.