Mariah Carey Kicks Off Holiday Music Debate Early This Year

WASHINGTON, D.C. — On November 1, Mariah Carey declared the start of the holiday season, reigniting discussions about when Christmas music should begin playing. Her iconic song, “All I Want for Christmas Is You,” serves as a seasonal anthem for fans, but some feel the announcement is premature.

Carey, often dubbed the “unofficial Christmas ambassador,” prompted a lively debate among the staff of NPR’s All Things Considered. Host Scott Detrow led the conversation, questioning when the right time is to start playing Christmas music.

Director Jonas Adams expressed his discontent, stating, “It’s too early for Christmas music. I just took Halloween decorations down.” Producer Vincent Acovino added, “You have to distill that spirit into a week, not two months. It’s ridiculous.” Their comments highlight a common sentiment that Christmas should wait until after Thanksgiving.

Elena Burnett, another producer, shared her opinion that while she loves Christmas music, starting too early leads to burnout by the holiday. “I want to enjoy it when it matters most,” she said.

Producer Erika Ryan took a stronger stance, sharing her experience in retail. “If it was up to me, there would be no Christmas music in public places,” she remarked. Many in the team agreed that the music should wait until at least the day after Thanksgiving.

In contrast, some staff members relish embracing holiday cheer early, even amidst ongoing disagreements about the timing. The conversation also reflects a larger cultural debate surrounding holiday commercialization and its impact on traditions.

With Thanksgiving still weeks away, the staff at All Things Considered wishes listeners a Merry Christmas, regardless of differing opinions on holiday music.