British Columbia Cabinet Minister Steps Down Over Controversial Remarks on Modern Israel

British Columbia‘s Post-Secondary Education Minister, Selina Robinson, has announced her resignation from her cabinet position following a firestorm of criticism over her recent comments on the foundation of modern Israel. Robinson referred to the region as a ‘crappy piece of land’ during a panel discussion, sparking outrage from various groups.

British Columbia Premier, David Eby, stated that Robinson’s remarks were incompatible with her remaining in cabinet, resulting in her decision to step down. However, Robinson will continue to serve as a member of the NDP caucus. Eby highlighted the significant amount of work required for Robinson to address the harm caused by her comments.

This controversy arose after a panel discussion hosted by B’nai Brith Canada, where Robinson expressed frustration over the lack of knowledge among younger generations about the foundation of modern Israel. Her comments, characterizing the land as unproductive and uninhabited, were seen as dismissive of the history and experiences of the Palestinian people.

Robinson issued two apologies for her comments, initially stating that they were disrespectful, and later acknowledging the need to undertake anti-Islamophobia training to better understand the concerns expressed to her. However, representatives from over a dozen B.C. mosques and Islamic associations called for Robinson’s removal and a ban on NDP MLAs and candidates from sacred spaces until action was taken.

Protests took place outside the provincial NDP caucus retreat, with organizers delivering a petition carrying over 11,000 signatures calling for Robinson’s resignation. While some welcomed her departure and expressed a willingness to engage in meaningful conversations, the Jewish Federation of Greater Vancouver described it as shocking, particularly at a time when Jewish students face increasing intimidation on campuses.

The resignation of Robinson poses a political challenge for Premier David Eby, with key events such as the throne speech and annual budget coming up. Eby aims to refocus the government’s message and move forward from the controversy.