Media Critic Gary Deeb Dies at 79, Leaving a Controversial Legacy

CHICAGO, Ill. — Gary Deeb, a prominent media critic known for his biting commentary, died on May 17 at the age of 79. His obituary appeared in The Buffalo News, the same newspaper where he began his career as a radio and TV columnist in 1970.

Deeb, who moved to Chicago in 1973 to join the Chicago Tribune, quickly became recognized for his brash and often controversial critiques. By 30, his column was syndicated widely, and he became a significant voice in media reporting.

Described as “arrogant, snippy, opinionated,” and more, Deeb’s tough persona was highlighted by his peers. Time magazine once labeled him “Terror of the Tube,” showcasing both his impact and his harsh style. He famously criticized many programs and their stars, expressing little regard for conventional niceties.

His opinions shaped how viewers perceived television, often painting local on-air personalities with a scathing brush. Most notably, he once referred to Jane Pauley as having “the IQ of a cantaloupe.” His criticism was not limited to individual shows but extended to the industry as a whole, calling the television landscape “devoid of innovation.”

After working at the Chicago Tribune, Deeb transitioned to a TV commentator role at ABC 7 in Chicago in 1983 and retired in Buffalo at age 50. A memorial service will be announced at a later date. Deeb is survived by his sister Elaine Lamb and stepdaughter Kyla Lee.

Philip Potempa, a journalist and author, met Deeb’s colleagues during his career and noted that while Deeb’s writing was entertaining, it often left individuals feeling harshly judged. Deeb’s sharp wit and critical eye will be missed by many in the media landscape.