Premier League Early Grades: Teams Assess Their First Month

September 19, 2025 — As the 2023-2024 Premier League season unfolds, teams are evaluated based on their early performances. The first month of competition serves as a critical period where clubs can set the tone for the rest of the season. This article provides a comprehensive analysis of each of the 20 teams, assigning grades that reflect their performances in the opening matches.

Manchester City, the reigning champions, have kicked off their season in spectacular fashion. Dominating possession and showcasing their trademark attacking prowess, they’ve secured victories with a blend of skill and strategy. Their 4-0 win against a strong opponent in the early weeks highlighted their attacking depth under the management of Pep Guardiola.

Arsenal has also impressed, demonstrating a strong commitment to their attacking philosophy while maintaining solid defensive organization. Mikel Arteta’s side has not only collected points but has done so with an exciting style of play. A notable 3-1 victory against Chelsea showcased their offensive capabilities.

Liverpool has made a strong statement with their performances in the first month, winning convincingly. Jurgen Klopp’s tactical acumen has been evident, especially in their thrilling 5-2 win against Newcastle United, where Mohamed Salah excelled.

Tottenham has surprised many with their robust performances this season. Manager Ange Postecoglou’s tactics have revitalized the squad, evident in their 2-0 win over Manchester United.

Brighton has continued to build on past successes, showcasing strong midfield control and winning 3-1 against Everton. Newcastle, with significant investments, has shown resilience but needs sharper finishing to improve further after a 2-1 win against Aston Villa.

Aston Villa’s early matches reflect potential but also moments of vulnerability, exemplified by their 2-2 draw against Chelsea. Meanwhile, Chelsea has struggled to find consistency, evidenced by mixed results including a disappointing 1-1 draw with Fulham.

Manchester United’s start has been disappointing, struggling with cohesion and defensive issues exemplified by their 2-0 loss to Tottenham. Wolverhampton has shown glimpses of potential but lacks results to match their performances.

Everton has faced a challenging start with a 3-0 defeat to Manchester City exacerbating their situation. Fulham has found it hard to adapt to the demands of the league, highlighting a pressing need for improvement.

Luton Town and Sheffield United have had tough introductions to the Premier League, each facing several heavy defeats, underscoring the urgent need for tactical adjustments to avoid relegation.

The first month provides a clear view of strengths and weaknesses across the league. Teams must adapt quickly to the demands of top-flight football as they move forward in the season.