Cato Town Elections Turned by Write-In Candidates

Cato, N.Y. — In a surprising turn of events, residents of Cato, a small town in Cayuga County, mounted a write-in campaign for all five town positions just weeks before the elections. Traditionally, there were no challengers for these roles, but this year, a full slate of candidates emerged, demonstrating the town’s desire for change.

The write-in campaign gathered momentum in late September when several townspeople expressed frustration over a series of issues, including allegations of illegal town meetings and administrative turnover. Residents began to engage more actively, culminating in a movement that resulted in significant voter turnout.

Among the candidates, retired paralegal Jessica Pelkey stepped up to run for town clerk after feeling a responsibility to manage taxes and paperwork. Pelkey reached out to voters directly, informing them on how to write her name on the ballot. “No matter who you are voting for, this election is evidence of the strength and benefit of our democratic republic,” she stated on social media.

Former town clerk Jody Snyder also campaigned as a write-in candidate for town supervisor after years of notable service in the town. Together with other candidates, they organized meet-and-greet events and engaged with voters at town board meetings.

By Election Day, the write-in slate had transformed into a formidable force, sweeping every town position. Snyder received over 70% of the votes, defeating incumbent Charles Ray 421 to 165. Pelkey also claimed a substantial majority, indicating a clear shift in political sentiment among Cato’s residents.

This year’s elections have become a testimony to the power of democratic participation in a small community. “It’s the right thing to do for my community,” Pelkey concluded, reflecting on the significance of the write-in candidates’ victories.