Lindor Discusses Captaincy While Alonso’s Future Uncertain for Mets

Flushing, New York — As the 2025 MLB season approaches, speculation grows regarding whether star shortstop Francisco Lindor will be named the fifth official captain in New York Mets history. Lindor expressed his thoughts during an episode of The Show: A NY Post Baseball Podcast, stating, “If it does happen, it would be an honor, and something that I wouldn’t take for granted.” He emphasized his view on leadership, saying, “You know, I will continue to be Francisco Lindor… It would be extremely special. It’s something that I could tell my kids and my grandkids one day.”

While Lindor is seen as a leader in the Mets’ clubhouse, other contenders for the captaincy exist. Juan Soto has voiced support for veteran Starling Marte, declaring him “literally the leader of this team.” Another candidate is Brandon Nimmo, who has spent the longest time with the Mets among current players, having been drafted in 2011. Former Mets reliever Adam Ottavino, in a recent YouTube video, commented on Nimmo’s competitive nature and the potential tension surrounding the captaincy discussion.

Ottavino remarked on Nimmo’s emotional response back when he felt slighted regarding media coverage that excluded him from a Yankees-Mets lineup. He speculated that Nimmo might not welcome discussions about Lindor’s potential captaincy. Nonetheless, Ottavino acknowledges that having played with Nimmo, he might have insight into his feelings.

The Mets’ offseason decisions also depend heavily on the future of slugger Pete Alonso. His potential departure could lead the team to explore significant moves in free agency as they prepare for the next season. However, if Alonso remains with the team, it may limit their other acquisitions. The Mets currently have options at first base, with players like Brett Baty, Ronny Mauricio, and Mark Vientos ready to step in if necessary. Vientos recently participated in the Mets’ annual turkey drive and commented on his preparation for both third and first base.

Vientos stated, “I haven’t heard anything about where my spot’s going to be, but I’m working at third and first base.” His versatility could play an essential role if Alonso signs with another team this winter. Nonetheless, Vientos expressed the importance of Alonso’s return to the Mets, describing him as integral to the team’s chance at a World Series. He said, “It’d be a great, great thing for him to come back to the team and help us win a World Series.” The situation remains fluid, and fans are advised not to interpret Vientos’ comments as an indicator of Alonso’s departure.