Yankees, Mets Discussed Major Trade Before Deadline

NEW YORK, NY — As the 2025 MLB trade deadline approached, the New York Yankees and Mets engaged in discussions about a high-profile trade involving center fielder Trent Grisham and third baseman Brett Baty. Reports indicate that the talks revolved around a one-for-one deal aimed at fulfilling both teams’ needs.

Prior to the deadline, the Mets sought Grisham to bolster their outfield defense and add offensive firepower. Meanwhile, the Yankees were interested in acquiring Baty for his controllable future as a potential solution at third base. The situation became more complicated due to Yankees star Aaron Judge‘s elbow injury, which had initially raised concerns about the team’s direction heading into the deadline.

Judge sustained the injury while throwing from right field on July 22, 2025. Consequentially, he was placed on the 10-day injured list. Fortunately for the Yankees, doctors later confirmed that Judge’s elbow issue was a minor flexor strain without any UCL damage. This news allowed the team to reconsider selling key players.

According to Yankees insider Andy Martino, losing Judge would have significantly altered their plans to trade pending free agents. The Yankees had previously considered selling Grisham and other players due to their underwhelming performance in the months of June and July.

Despite some early struggles, the Yankees turned things around, finishing the season with a strong run. They held onto Grisham, who has established himself with a career-high 34 home runs this season. His performances were crucial for the Yankees as they continued to vie for the AL East title, demonstrating the impact of keeping him on the roster.

Baty, on the other hand, has had a mixed season with the Mets. After being demoted earlier in the season due to poor performance, he rebounded with solid statistics, including a .254 batting average and 18 home runs. His development appeared to highlight the Mets’ decision-making at the deadline.

While the trade never materialized, it was indicative of the complex decision-making processes both teams face. Ultimately, the Yankees opted not to move Grisham and instead brought in veterans like Ryan McMahon. The Mets targeted Cedric Mullins, who has since struggled in New York.

As the teams reflect on the decisions made at the deadline, both organizations might feel satisfied with how the situation unfolded. The Yankees have a player in Grisham who continues to contribute significantly, while the Mets have Baty, a young talent they can potentially rely on moving forward.