Chloé Zhao’s ‘Hamnet’ Draws Mixed Reactions at Toronto International Film Festival

Toronto, Canada — Chloé Zhao‘s highly anticipated film “Hamnet” premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF) this week, generating a whirlwind of reactions from audiences and critics alike. Based on Maggie O'Farrell‘s 2020 novel, the film explores the themes of grief and creativity through the lens of William Shakespeare‘s life and his relationship with his wife, Agnes.

“Hamnet” won the People’s Choice Award at TIFF, raising expectations significantly. Focus Features promoted the film with a quote from The Rolling Tape, claiming it was ‘Not just the best picture of the year, the best film ever made.’ Despite the hype, viewers have expressed diverse feelings about the film, with some praising its emotional depth and others criticizing its portrayal of tragic events.

Jessie Buckley stars as Agnes, while Paul Mescal plays Shakespeare. Critics noted that the film delves into the emotional turmoil surrounding the death of their son, Hamnet, who is believed to have died of the plague at the young age of 11. The movie presents a blend of magical realism and historical context, prompting some to question its accuracy.

The film showcases moments of intense grief, particularly in scenes where Agnes grapples with her son’s death. One noteworthy sequence features Buckley’s heart-wrenching performance, generating both applause and discomfort among viewers. A segment showcasing Hamnet’s demise has drawn particular criticism for its dramatic presentation, stirring debates about its appropriateness.

As audiences noted the stark emotional contrasts, reactions varied widely. While some viewers reportedly walked out during particularly difficult scenes, there were also extended applause at the end of screenings, signifying a passionate response to the film’s powerful themes.

As with Zhao’s previous works, including the Oscar-winning “Nomadland,” visual storytelling remains central in “Hamnet.” The cinematography captures the contrast between the lush landscape and the raw emotions of its characters, creating an immersive viewing experience. Critics have highlighted the combination of dramatic acting and rich visual elements as key strengths of the film.

Overall, “Hamnet” has sparked significant conversation about its implications on the nature of grief and art. Zhao’s adaptation has drawn comparisons to past works, particularly Kenneth Branagh’s depiction of Shakespeare’s later years in “All Is True.” While the narrative diverges from traditional historical accounts, its emotional core resonates deeply with the audience.

The film will open in theaters on November 26, inviting a wider audience to engage with its complex themes and examine their own interpretations of Shakespeare’s legacy and parental loss.