Controversial Docuseries Examines Vince McMahon’s Dual Identity

In a newly released six-part docuseries on Netflix, titled “Mr. McMahon,” the complex and often controversial life of former WWE CEO Vince McMahon is explored. The docuseries aims to provide an in-depth look into McMahon’s substantial influence on the global wrestling industry while also delving into the personal and professional controversies that have surrounded him.

During an interview in the final episode, McMahon himself reflects on the blurred lines between his real identity and the on-screen persona of “Mr. McMahon.” He admits, “I’m wondering myself now, which is the character and which is me? I guess maybe it’s a blend. I would suggest that one is exaggerated a little bit, but I’m not so sure which one.”

This introspective comment sets the tone for the series, which does not shy away from highlighting McMahon’s achievements in transforming WWE into a global powerhouse while also addressing the numerous controversies, including allegations of drug and steroid abuse and accusations related to sexual misconduct.

The docuseries, which began production in 2021, faced interruptions in 2022 due to new reporting on alleged attempts to conceal sexual misconduct. Director Chris Smith uses these challenges to portray a candid, albeit incomplete, portrait of McMahon. The series was developed with the cooperation of WWE, though McMahon and WWE did not exercise editorial control, which contributes to the multi-faceted depiction presented.

Notably, the series examines McMahon’s business strategies, his relentless drive to make WWE a national entity, and the pivotal “Attitude Era” that revolutionized wrestling’s popularity. WWE legend Tony Atlas commends McMahon as “the greatest promoter of all time,” while wrestling star The Undertaker expresses personal loyalty, saying he would “take a bullet” for McMahon.

Conversely, the series also reveals the darker side of McMahon’s leadership, where wrestlers often faced severe consequences for defying his directives. Trish Stratus recounts an incident where her refusal to partake in a controversial storyline seemingly resulted in the loss of her Women’s Championship title.

The series highlights McMahon’s dismissive attitude towards allegations of sexual misconduct, including those made by former referee Rita Marie. Atlas mentions that in the company’s early days, women were treated poorly, stating, “we abused the hell out of women. All of us did.”

One of the more controversial moments discussed is McMahon’s decision to continue a wrestling event following the tragic death of Owen Hart. McMahon rationalized this choice by suggesting that he would have wanted “the show to go on” if he were in Hart’s position, displaying a contentious prioritization of entertainment over sensitivity to the tragedy.

Episode five provides insight into Vince’s family, where his wife Linda and children Shane and Stephanie offer a glimpse into their perspectives, though they stop short of revealing everything. This segment is noted as one of the more compelling parts of the series.

Overall, the docuseries presents a narrative that intertwines Vince McMahon’s personal identity with his wrestling persona, painting a complicated picture of a man who has left an indelible mark on professional wrestling. Interviewees provide varying opinions on whether Vince and “Mr. McMahon” are indeed the same, highlighting the complexity of his personality.