John Smoltz Faces Backlash for Yankees Comments During ALDS Broadcast

NEW YORK, NY — John Smoltz, a commentator for FOX Sports and former Atlanta Braves pitcher, faced backlash from New York Yankees fans during Game 2 of the American League Division Series. In the midst of the game against the Toronto Blue Jays, Smoltz stated, “They don’t value what you need to win games,” prompting an outcry from fans who felt disrespected.

Smoltz, who is known for his strong opinions, had previously ignited controversy in 2020 when he compared Yankee Stadium’s field dimensions to those of Coors Field, implying that the Bronx ballpark favors hitters too much. Yankees fans have viewed such comments as a challenge to the team’s legacy and reputation as a tough venue for pitchers.

A fan took to social media, expressing frustration with his comments. “Shut up, John Smoltz!” was among the many responses that flooded the internet. This is not the first time Smoltz has drawn ire from Yankees supporters; his 1996 World Series loss against the Yankees continues to haunt him.

During his career, Smoltz delivered impressive performances, including a remarkable 0.64 ERA in the 1996 World Series, yet he still suffered a 1-0 loss to Yankees pitcher Andy Pettitte. His history with the team seems to color his commentary, leading some to speculate that he holds a grudge that seeps into his analysis.

Critics argue that Smoltz’s remarks create a hostile environment when discussing the Yankees, with fans calling his commentary biased and exhausting. One viewer tweeted, “John Smoltz is the worst baseball commentator on television that I have had the misfortune to watch,” emphasizing the frustration felt by many during broadcasts.

Even those who enjoy his analysis struggle with the apparent favoritism he shows toward opposing teams. “John Smoltz just said that Max Fried’s velocity going up is bad for Max Fried #DoYouHaveAlzheimer’s,” a fan tweeted, highlighting the confusion his commentary can cause.

As the postseason continues, every mention of the Yankees by Smoltz seems to ignite further debate among fans. Many are left wondering how a storied pitching career can cloud one’s judgment in the broadcast booth. For New York Yankees fans, the stakes are high not only on the field but also in the narrative surrounding their team.