Broadway’s ‘Just in Time’ Struggles to Capture Bobby Darin’s Essence

NEW YORK — Jonathan Groff stars in the new jukebox musical, ‘Just in Time,’ which opened on April 26, 2025, at the Circle in the Square Theatre. The show explores the life of Bobby Darin, a pop sensation known for hits like ‘Mack the Knife’ and ‘Dream Lover.’ Despite its vibrant musical numbers, critics argue that the production fails to provide a comprehensive portrait of Darin.

‘Just in Time,’ written by Warren Leight and Isaac Oliver, focuses on a period of Darin’s life beginning with his music career at age 19 and concluding shortly before his death at 37. The musical showcases various songs from Darin’s catalog but includes many tunes that he did not perform, diluting the intent of a biographical tribute.

Critics have noted that the production resembles a tribute concert more than a cohesive narrative. Groff interacts with the audience and embodies Darin’s charismatic stage presence, but shifts between the character and his own persona leave audiences struggling to connect with Darin’s story.

The set design by Derek McLane captures a glamorous nightclub atmosphere, but critics argue it restricts the storytelling potential. Groff, a Tony Award winner, delivers energetic performances but is hindered by a script that lacks depth and character development for those surrounding him.

In one of the musical’s most poignant moments, Dodd Darin, Bobby’s son, recounts a family secret that profoundly affected his father’s life. Such revelations add emotional weight, yet the overall portrayal has been criticized for oversimplifying Darin’s complexities.

The production showcases a live band and features notable songs, but its narrative arc often feels rushed. As the show concludes, it reportedly opts for a celebratory tone rather than a reflective assessment of Darin’s tumultuous life.

While efforts are made to honor Bobby Darin’s legacy, critics suggest the show ultimately may not resonate with audiences unfamiliar with his music. ‘Just in Time’ is now scheduled to run through November 30, 2025, allowing fans the opportunity to explore this musical tribute to a complicated pop icon.