Giants’ Playoff Hopes Rest on Andrew Thomas’ Recovery

East Rutherford, New Jersey — The New York Giants are facing a pivotal moment in their 2025 season as the health of offensive tackle Andrew Thomas takes center stage. Following a disappointing loss to the Washington Commanders, the Giants’ offensive line struggled without Thomas, leaving quarterback Russell Wilson vulnerable and ineffective.

In Week 1 against Washington, the offensive front suffered greatly in Thomas’ absence. James Hudson, who filled in at left tackle, allowed six pressures and committed a penalty during the game. His performance drew criticism, especially considering his $12 million contract, which many viewed as questionable after this showing. With Wilson pressured consistently, the offense was unable to establish any rhythm.

The Giants have yet to decide if Thomas, who is recovering from an injury, will return for their upcoming game against the Dallas Cowboys. If Thomas is not cleared, the team may need to rely on rookie Marcus Mbow, who showed promise during preseason practices. However, facing the Cowboys’ fierce pass rush would be a daunting challenge for the rookie.

Thomas is a key player for the Giants, having been a Pro Bowl tackle when healthy. Unfortunately, injuries have plagued his recent seasons, making his durability a concern for the team. The Giants have invested heavily in him, committing $117.5 million, and they need him on the field. The coaching staff understands that without Thomas, their chances against elite defenses are greatly diminished.

The lack of protection not only hinders Wilson’s ability to perform but also disrupts the run game, limiting offensive options. The Giants’ offensive line has already shown weaknesses, and every moment without stability puts pressure on the entire team. They face a difficult road ahead if Thomas cannot return to full practice by the end of the week.

Head coach Brian Daboll confirmed that Thomas is following a “ramp plan” for his recovery. While the team remains hopeful that he may practice later this week, his unavailability could exacerbate the damage done in the last game. With Dallas ready to exploit any weaknesses, rushing Thomas back could either save the season or cause further risks.

The Giants’ performance against the Cowboys depends largely on Thomas’ health. If he cannot make a full recovery in time, Wilson may once again find himself surrounded by an underperforming lineup. As the Giants prepare for what could be a defining game, all focus rests on whether Thomas can make it back onto the field safely.