Speaker faces backlash over Gaza ceasefire motion selection in Commons chaos

The Commons descended into chaos as the Speaker faced backlash over his handling of the Gaza ceasefire motion selection. The selection of two amendments to the SNP motion caused uproar, leading to a stormy session where SNP and Tory MPs staged dramatic walkouts. Lindsay Hoyle, the Speaker, expressed regret for the contentious turn of events.

A vote was taken on whether to close the chamber to the press and public during the tense standoff over the amendments. Interestingly, the bid to shut out outsiders failed, with only 20 MPs supporting the motion. The vote’s delay was instigated by Tory MPs staging a sit-in protest in the No lobby.

The amended Labour motion, which ultimately bypassed a vote on the original SNP motion, was nodded through. However, even this course of action sparked further dispute. In a dramatic turn, the government withdrew its own amendment in protest of the Speaker’s decision.

Lindsay Hoyle later issued a statement of apology, acknowledging that his actions were driven by concerns for the security of members and their families. He stated that his intention was to ensure all MPs could have a say and express their views. Hoyle expressed sincere apologies to all, particularly targeting the SNP, and expressed a desire to engage in discussions with all concerned parties promptly.

SNP Westminster leader, Stephen Flynn, voiced skepticism and hinted that he would need strong persuasion to believe the Speaker’s position remained tenable. Allegations circulated that Hoyle had a meeting with Sue Gray, Chief of Staff to Keir Starmer, though the Speaker firmly denied this assertion. Speculations also swirled regarding pressure from Starmer on Hoyle.